Concrete pavers
Pavers are made in a factory, so every piece is the same size and thickness. That gives you a flat, even surface that is easy to set furniture and a grill on, and a clean, consistent look. Patterns, colors and textures run from classic brick shapes to large slabs that look like cut stone.
Their best feature is that they come apart. Pavers sit on a bed of sand over a compacted stone base, with sand in the joints. If one cracks, or the patio settles in a spot, the pavers there can be lifted and the base fixed underneath, then the same pavers go back down. A poured slab cannot do that.
The joints need a little care: sand settles over time and can be topped up, and weeds can root in joints that stay open. Polymeric joint sand, which stiffens once wet, cuts down on both.
Natural stone
Flagstone and other natural stone are quarried slabs, so no two pieces match. Sandstone, bluestone and limestone are common choices, in irregular shapes for a relaxed look or cut into rectangles for a more formal one. Stone blends into planting beds and boulders in a way manufactured pavers do not.
Natural stone takes more hand work. Pieces vary in thickness and shape, so each one is fitted and leveled on its own. That labor is a big part of the price. Stone can be dry-laid on a compacted base with stone dust or gravel in the joints, or set in mortar on a concrete slab. Mortared joints look tidy, but if the slab underneath moves with frost, they can crack.
In Ohio, the base matters more than the top
Northeast Ohio freezes and thaws over and over each winter. Water that collects under a patio freezes, expands and lifts the surface, then lets it drop again in spring. Do that for a few winters on a thin or poorly drained base and any patio, paver or stone, ends up uneven.
A patio that stays flat starts with:
- a base of crushed stone, compacted in layers rather than dumped in all at once;
- a slope that carries water away from the house;
- a separation fabric (geotextile) between the base and clay soil, which the hardscape industry’s technical guidance recommends where clay and freeze and thaw meet;
- for pavers, a solid edge restraint so the field cannot creep outward.
Clay soil is common in our area, and it drains slowly, so the base work is where a good patio and a bad one part ways.
Side by side
- Look: pavers are uniform and crisp; natural stone is varied and organic.
- Surface: pavers are flatter for chairs and tables; stone has more texture and natural variation.
- Repairs: pavers lift out and go back; dry-laid stone can be reset; mortared stone needs mortar repair.
- Upkeep: both need joints topped up now and then; sealing is optional for both.
- Price: material choice, cut stone versus irregular, thickness, access for equipment, removal of an old patio and added steps or walls all move the number. Ask for each one to be priced on its own line.
Questions to ask any patio installer
- How deep will the base be, what stone goes in it, and will it be compacted in layers?
- Will there be fabric between the base and our clay soil?
- Which way will water run off the patio?
- What holds the edges in place?
- What goes in the joints?
- Is removing the old patio or soil on the estimate, and as its own line?
We build patios, walkways, steps and retaining walls in natural flagstone, interlocking pavers and poured concrete, and we talk through the look and the budget for each at your free estimate. See patios, walkways and retaining walls or photos of our flagstone patios and walkways.