Ideas and advice

Repair or replace your deck? What to check first

Start under the deck, not on top of it. Worn boards and a wobbly railing can usually be repaired. Rot in the joists or the ledger board, footings that have moved, or a ledger that was never bolted and flashed usually mean replacement. If the frame is sound, new boards and railings on the old frame can make sense.

By Exterior Installations ·

Start with the ledger

The ledger is the board that fastens the deck to the house. It carries one end of every joist, so it is the first thing to check. Look for:

  • bolts or structural screws through the ledger into the house framing, not just nails;
  • metal flashing over the top of the ledger, so rain cannot run behind it and rot the house’s rim board;
  • dark stains, soft wood or mushrooms on the ledger or the house framing behind it.

A ledger attached to brick or stone veneer is a red flag; building departments do not allow it. Strongsville’s deck guidelines, for example, say ledgers shall not be attached to veneers and require continuous flashing where a ledger meets wood framing.

Then the footings and posts

Each post should sit on a concrete footing deep enough to stay below the frost line, or the deck will heave in winter. Your building department sets the depth; in Northeast Ohio it is commonly between 36 and 42 inches, and Strongsville’s handout lists 39 inches. Leaning posts, posts sitting on blocks at the surface, and rot where a post meets the ground all point to footing problems.

Joists and beams

Push a screwdriver into the framing under the deck, especially the tops of the joists and the cut ends where water sits. Pressure-treated framing lasts a long time, but it is not rot-proof. If the screwdriver sinks in easily in more than a few spots, the frame is near the end of its life.

Boards, railings and stairs

Cupped, split or soft boards and popped fasteners are surface problems; boards can be replaced. Railings matter more. Grab each post and push. A guard is required where a deck is more than 30 inches above the ground, and it has to be at least 36 inches tall with openings small enough that a 4-inch ball cannot pass through. Check stair stringers for rot where they meet the ground, too.

Repair, resurface or replace?

  • Repair when a few boards, a loose railing or a step are the only problems and the frame is solid.
  • Resurface when the frame, ledger and footings are sound but the boards and railings are worn out. New decking and railings on the old frame can make sense, as long as the frame has plenty of life left. Composite boards have their own joist spacing rules, often 16 inches apart or less and closer for boards laid on a diagonal, so check the maker’s spacing against your frame first.
  • Replace when the ledger or framing is rotted, the footings have moved, or you want a bigger or different deck. A new deck is also the time to fix a ledger that was never flashed or bolted.

Composite or wood?

Composite decking, like Trex, costs more up front but does not need staining or sealing; an occasional wash keeps it clean. Pressure-treated wood costs less to build but needs cleaning and a fresh coat of stain or sealer every few years to hold up to Ohio weather. Many homeowners pair a treated lumber frame with composite boards and railings.

Before you build

Most Northeast Ohio cities and townships require a permit for a new deck, and some for a rebuild, so check with your building department. A deck estimate should list tear-out and haul-off, framing, flashing, decking and railing so you can compare like with like.

We tear out old decks and build new ones with treated lumber framing, proper flashing, and composite decking and railing such as Trex. See deck building and replacement.

Sources